Multiple Reviews

This Ain't No Ukelele: Jazz Guitarists Anthony Wilson, Daniel Santiago and John Pondel

By
MARTIN GLADU,
Martin Gladu

Martin Gladu

CD/DVD Reviewer since 2006

Martin Gladu is a guitarist, consultant and music publishing/licensing veteran.

Recent articles (79 total)

Published: August 27, 2009

For better or worse, the electric guitar has generally projected an image of masculinity, a certain macho quality even. Perfect examples of this are the scenes involving Steve Vai's Jack Butler character in Walter Hill's Crossroads (Columbia Pictures, 1986). Cruelly demanding, the instrument has bruised many male egos and crushed their dreams of stardom and fame.

It has also been reported that the guitar gives its owner the power of attraction over the opposite sex. Well, with each new sale lost to a gaming console or a cellphone, the relevance of this suggestion has waned more and more as time goes by. And, if the ability to thrum but a few chords ever had such subliminal power, one must concur with Bob DylanBob Dylan Bob Dylan
b.1941
composer/conductor
that the times they are indeed a-changin.' This raises concerns. Has music lost the youth's interests? Are the new, digital products of the entertainment and communications industries that much more appealing?

Take for example Jimi HendrixJimi Hendrix Jimi Hendrix
1942 - 1970
guitar, electric
and Pete Townsend. In their hands, the instrument was often used as an object of spectacle. Then with Eddie Van Halen and Steve VaiSteve Vai Steve Vai
it became more pyrotechnic. Yet, in the hands of acoustic players like Egberto GismontiEgberto Gismonti Egberto Gismonti
b.1947
guitar, acoustic
, Michael Hedges or John RenbournJohn Renbourn John Renbourn
, among others, it took on a powerful—if quieter—role. The instrument has undergone an impressive development in the jazz world as well. From Eddie LangEddie Lang Eddie Lang
1902 - 1933
guitar
, Django ReinhardtDjango Reinhardt Django Reinhardt
1910 - 1953
guitar
and Charlie ChristianCharlie Christian Charlie Christian
1916 - 1942
guitar, electric
, to Eivind AarsetEivind Aarset Eivind Aarset

guitar
and Wayne KrantzWayne Krantz Wayne Krantz
b.1956
guitar
, it appears a different instrument altogether. In fact, since Jim HallJim Hall Jim Hall
b.1930
guitar
, the six-string guitar acquired a stylized, more introspective temperament, which effected the slew of players who were to follow.

Each in his own way, Anthony WilsonAnthony Wilson Anthony Wilson
b.1968
guitar
, Daniel Santiago and John Pondel represent the wide variety of styles going under the generic term "jazz guitar."

Anthony Wilson Trio
Jack Of Hearts
Groove Note Records
2009

A neo-traditionalist in the same vein as Mark Whitfield and Russell MaloneRussell Malone Russell Malone
b.1963
guitar, electric
, Anthony Wilson is not one to shrug off his instrument's blues roots or long history as a tool of groove. As a matter of fact, when he is not busy laying it down behind jazz diva Diana KrallDiana Krall Diana Krall
b.1964
piano
, Wilson is often found in the studio supporting other chart-topping acts like Chris Botti, Michael Buble, and Queen Latifah. A groovy, jazz-meets-pop-meets-funk affair, his Jack Of Hearts appears like a hidden card he is been itching to pull from his sleeve. Organist Larry GoldingsLarry Goldings Larry Goldings
b.1968
keyboard
and top-notch session drummers Jeff HamiltonJeff Hamilton Jeff Hamilton
b.1953
drums
and Jim Keltner are there to ensure his is a winning hand.

At times reminiscent of Wes MontgomeryWes Montgomery Wes Montgomery
1925 - 1968
guitar
's debut for Prestige with Melvin Rhyne, at others of Grant GreenGrant Green Grant Green
1935 - 1979
guitar
's soul-jazz sessions, Wilson happily opens up the somewhat stigmatized format to some crossover imports. As the spirit of down-home blues, re-arranged pop tunes and B3-brindled ballads mixes in amicably with the organ-trio idiom, this approach—though arguably less exciting than most "standard" organ trios - should appeal more to casual listeners than to die-hard jazz fans. The latter will most likely find the presence of that idiomatic, pumped-on-testosterone feel such units carry more contained here. It is. But, whether Wilson's approach is original or not is besides the point. What is of importance is whether he and his acolytes can impart the fun they have making this music. From the get go, with the opening track "Mezcal," it is unquestionably evident these guys had a blast making this recording.

Daniel Santiago
Metropole
Adventure Music
2009

Daniel Santiago is also not one to take the fun out of playing the guitar, quite the contrary. Hailing from Brazil, Santiago favours a collegial approach to composition, putting his sizzling melodies through a dangerously nervous rhythmic machine and then toning it down to acoustic-set, pastoral vistas. But, as its title suggests, the idea behind Metropole is of conjuring up a bustling urban landscape, of vertically stacked harmonic-rhythmic structures with reserved pathways for zigzagging soloists. The listener comes out of the excursion alive, and longing for more.

A skilled technician and composer, Santiago shares conceptions of phrasing and tone with Pat MethenyPat Metheny Pat Metheny
b.1954
guitar
. His winning tandem with saxophonist Josue Lopez is reminiscent of the Brazil-bound master's collaborations with saxophonist Michael BreckerMichael Brecker Michael Brecker
1949 - 2007
sax, tenor
. "Traveling" and "Miracle are two telling examples. His pensive "Children Of The War" calls to meditation in much the same way that Metheny's "Message To A Friend" did on the Beyond The Missouri Sky (Verve, 1997) project with bassist Charlie HadenCharlie Haden Charlie Haden
b.1937
bass, acoustic
. That said, this second outing reveals Santiago as a talented, maturing voice whose influences, though watermarked, are rapidly overlooked for the superior quality of its presentation. A name to reckon with.

John Pondel
John Pondel
Real Guy Productions
2009

Active on the West Coast scene since his early twenties, it is surprising John Pondel has taken so long to come out with his first effort as a leader. A sophisticated, harmonic player a la Lenny BreauLenny Breau Lenny Breau
1941 - 1984
guitar
, Joe DiorioJoe Diorio Joe Diorio
b.1936
guitar
and Ted GreeneTed Greene Ted Greene
b.1946
guitar
, Pondel has played alongside trumpeter Snooky YoungSnooky Young Snooky Young
1919 - 2011
trumpet
and saxophonist Harold LandHarold Land Harold Land
1928 - 2001
sax, tenor
in the Grammy-winning Gerald WilsonGerald Wilson Gerald Wilson
b.1918
composer/conductor
Orchestra (led by the other, above-mentioned Wilson's father). He also co-leads acid-jazz pioneer unit Jazzhole with vocalist Marlon Saunders and keyboardist-producer Warren Rosenstein.

An elegant and classy stylist straight out of the Jim Hall tradition, Pondel, like his elder, has adopted effects to tinker the sound of his hollow-body guitar. Whereas Hall uses effects to harmonize single note lines with intervals otherwise unplayable or too taxing, Pondel's stomp box lowers the pitch of his phrases' last notes, thus producing microtonal glissandi ("reverse bends" in guitar terminology). When used too frequently—such as in the otherwise acceptable take of Horace SilverHorace Silver Horace Silver
b.1928
piano
's "The Jody Grind"—the gimmick becomes irritating. Considering Pondel's broad knowledge of voicings and textures, his reliance on such an aid appears unnecessary. In fact, his chording amply colors the sonic space, which remains austere with only percussionist Marivaldo Dos Santos, bassist Scott ColleyScott Colley Scott Colley

bass
and guest flautist/saxophonist David BinneyDavid Binney David Binney
b.1961
saxophone
filling in the backdrop. Such parred down instrumentation becomes an issue in the overall dynamics the trio project.

In this sense, the decision to feature Binney on flute—rather than saxophone—on two of his three appearances appears questionable. So is the selection of Dos Santos instead of a full-set drummer; his assortment of shells, drums and sonorous cymbals unfortunately does little to fill the sterile sonic landscape. Always solid, Colley claims the strongest voice here, which is especially manifest in his spirited soloing on "Jakes Dilemma" and "Waving Not Drowning," a cajoling composition despite its title. But, all things considered, Pondel's debut is a disappointing affair, especially considering the load of experience he brings to the table.

Docile or impudent, the electric guitar does have the power to paint many moods. In the right hands, such as the three practitioners above, its status in the jazz world is to be championed, with each new player coming and shaking its contentions anew. Let us hope many more of those are waiting in the wings.


Tracks and Personnel

Jack Of Hearts

Tracks: Mezcal; Jack of Hearts; Hawkeyes; Carnegie Blues; Theme from Chinatown; Vida Perdida Acabou; Orange Crate Art; Harajuku; Zweet Zursday; Homecoming.

Personnel: Anthony Wilson: guitar; Jim Keltner: drums (1, 5, 7, 8, 10); Jeff Hamilton: drums (2-4, 9); Larry Goldings: Hammond B-3 organ, celeste.

Metropole

Tracks: Old City; In The Rain; Gregorian Samba; Letter To The World; Children of the War; Salamandra; Traveling; Lagoon; Angola's Dance; Miracle; Within Us; Metropole.

Personnel: Daniel Santiago: guitars; Josue Lopez: tenor and soprano saxophone; Vitor Goncalves: piano; Marcio Bahia: drums (4, 5, 7, 9, 11, 12); Edu Ribeiro: drums (1-3, 6, 8, 10); Guto Wirtti: bass.

John Pondel

Tracks: Make It Nice; Jakes Dilemma; Mr. Obvious; HP; Waving Not Drowning; Where the River Ends; The Jody Grind; Ed Snipe.

Personnel: John Pondel: guitar; Scott Colley: bass; Marivaldo Dos Santos: percussion; David Binney: flute & alto saxophone.

comments powered by Disqus

Weekly Giveaways

Will Calhoun

Will Calhoun
About | Enter

Verve Jazz Ensemble

Verve Jazz Ensemble
About | Enter

Sinan Bakir

Sinan Bakir
About | Enter

Joshua Redman

Joshua Redman
About | Enter